Psychiatrist Discusses Reasons for Filicide, After U.S. Mom Is Charged With Murdering Her Children in Scotland
- Enjoy this article? Help vote it up the 'Vine.
- Public Discussion (9)
"We don't have all the facts yet. The case is still unfolding," points out Dr. Sara West, a forensic psychiatrist at Case Western Reserve University in Cleveland and a specialist in the phenomenon of parents who murder their children.
"What we do know is that parents sometimes who are stressed out by extreme life events, such as divorce, can take measures to get back at one another, such as killing the children. That would be a very extreme form."
On "The Early Show on Saturday Morning," Riggi described five reasons for co-anchor Ben Tracy that parents might take the lives of their own offspring.
- 1 vote
Altruism "refers to a parent who kills a child to relieve the suffering of the child," (...) because they either perceive the child to have a syndrome that would cause them to suffer, or they may have a real syndrome that causes them to suffer."
I'm a little put-off by the grouping of these two "reasons" together. Duly note, first and foremost that I do not condone killing a child, even for altruistic reasons; however, it is, in twisted minds, understandable why some parents might be inclined to kill their children if they suffer from an actual debilitating ailment.
I believe our reasoning gives us the ability to be more than just animals, but at our core physiological, un-nurtured and un-socially-adaptive existences, I admit, we are still merely animals. And while most of us have the higher-reasoning power and ability to overcome basal instincts such as killing a lame child -- our unsevered tether to the "animal kingdom" leaves, in the least, an academic comprehension of why one might possibly see altruism in childhood euthanasia.
I am not a psychologist/psychiatrist/sociologist; however, I hope that these sciences take into account the difference between truth and perception in cases such as this, because this article does not.
I'm not sure why you equate this with being animals. Most animals don't kill their young.
As to the difference between truth and perception, they are often one and the same to the person committing the murder. For instance, Andrea Tate was suffering from Postpartum Depression and delusions when she killed her kids to save them. It isn't rational to you or I, but I don't doubt she believed it to be true.
The delusional world of schizophrenia is as real to its victim as my world is to me.
- 1 vote
Most, if not ALL medications prescribed by psychiatrists for the predominant number of diagnosis' carry "Black Box Warnings" for violent side effects.
Most, if not ALL incidences of mass public killings can be linked to the use of these medications.
Their (the psychiatric industry) response is always that the medication DOESN'T cause violence, its the people.
But NONE of those people were committing mass homicide before they started taking medication.
#ITAIN'TROCKETSCIENCE
Filicide has been going on for centuries, long before the pharmaceutical industry even existed. While it may play a role in some, we certainly can't blame it for all.
- 1 vote
Filicide has been going on for centuries,
Not at the rates or frequency occurring now.
I don't know when you were in school but when I was in school there was NEVER any school mass killings.
Filicide is not school shooting. It is when a parent kills their child. If you want to argue that parents are murdering their children more today than throughout history, then I'm going to ask you to provide a link proving it.
There are cultures where it is tacitly endorsed, like in China or other nations where girl babies are murdered by the millions.
Gendercide Watch: Female Infanticide
The phenomenon of female infanticide is as old as many cultures, and has likely accounted for millions of gender-selective deaths throughout history. It remains a critical concern in a number of "Third World" countries today, notably the two most populous countries on earth, China and India. In all cases, specifically female infanticide reflects the low status accorded to women in most parts of the world; it is arguably the most brutal and destructive manifestation of the anti-female bias that pervades "patriarchal" societies. It is closely linked to the phenomena of sex-selective abortion, which targets female fetuses almost exclusively, and neglect of girl children.
Nonetheless, the argument advanced in the maternal mortality case-study holds true in this case as well: governments and other actors can be just as guilty of mass killing by neglect or tacit encouragement, as by direct murder. R.J. Rummel buttresses this view, referring to infanticide as
"another type of government killing whose victims may total millions ... In many cultures, government permitted, if not encouraged, the killing of handicapped or female infants or otherwise unwanted children. In the Greece of 200 B.C., for example, the murder of female infants was so common that among 6,000 families living in Delphi no more than 1 percent had two daughters."
My point is-- it doesn't matter WHO it is, when they ingest psychotropic drugs they have a greater risk of VIOLENCE by orders of MAGNITUDE. Parents as well.
That isn't true. Most psychotropic drugs do a lot of good. There have been very few that are questionable. It isn't hard to avoid them.
There have been many, many changes in our society that should be considered before anyone tries to blame any one factor. For instance, a media that glorifies violence as the way to solve problems. Illegal drugs. Increased pressure in an increasinglystressful society. Domestic abuse. Ghettoization of many communities. The list is long.
No one has the answers as to why any single person does any single thing, good or bad. To pretend it is one thing and one thing only is simplistic thinking about a complex problem caused by complex human beings.
But if you want to keep making the claim that parents are murdering their children due to psychotropic drugs, then please produce the relevant studies.
- 3 votes
You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead. |



